Is there a hidden temple theology in the Book of Mormon temple theology waiting beneath the 1830 text? That question, sparked by my friend Boyd in an online forum, turned into a three-part answer, and this is the final installment. While preparing, an AI tool handed me a word I had to look up: palimpsest, a manuscript scraped clean and written over, where the earlier text still shows through faintly. It turned out to be the perfect frame for the debate.
Temple Theology in the Book of Mormon
On one side are Val Larsen, Dave Butler (who writes on the temple as D. John Butler) and Don Bradley. Dave believes temple language appears in the very first verse, where Nephi says he was taught “the mysteries of God,” a phrase that in the ancient world pointed to initiatory rites. He reads the prison story in Helaman 5 as a four-stage temple drama: an outer court, a circle of fire like sacred robes, a guide named Aminadab, and a voice through the veil. Building on Jack Welch, he sees the Sermon on the Mount the same way. Val connects Lehi’s tree of life to the Divine Mother and argues that the veil once worn by women in the prayer circle placed them in her position. Don points to the brother of Jared speaking through a veil, and to an 1830 interview in which Joseph Smith Sr. reportedly said the plates bore Masonic symbols, years before Joseph joined the Masons in Nauvoo.
On the other side is historian Jonathan Stapley, author of Holiness to the Lord. Jonathan cautions against what he calls the teleological fallacy: reading highly developed 20th-century temple ideas back into an 1830 book. In his developmental view, the Nauvoo endowment grew out of Joseph’s 1842 Masonic initiation and the urgent need to bind families together before his death.
The forum did not let me off easy. Paul argued that the either/or framing is itself the mistake, though he leaned toward Stapley. A former Latter-day Saint explained that the Book of Mormon’s view of God, more Trinitarian than Utah theology, was part of his move to the Community of Christ. Val suggested the real divide is between a dispensational view, where the gospel is revealed, lost and restored, and an evolutionary one. New Testament scholar Chris Thomas even shared an actual palimpsest, the Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus, and observed that readers who already know the modern temple tend to be the ones who find it in the text. Paul also shared the story of how his wife’s conch-shell sketch shaped the Community of Christ temple in Independence.
Is the temple a restored ancient blueprint or a revelation that grew line upon line? Watch the full forum and decide which layer you see.
Listen to the full conversation wherever you get your podcasts.

I’m convinced that the primary authors of the Book of Mormon knew the mysteries. Now that’s not to say that what they were familiar with in terms of ritual and symbolism is precisely the same as our modern forms. But even so, there’re are distinct patterns that emerge all through the text that make it evident (to me at least) that Joseph Smith tapped into a temple theology that has very ancient roots. Here’s one small example from Alma 33:
4 For he said: Thou art merciful, O God, for thou hast heard my prayer, even when I was in the wilderness; yea, thou wast merciful when I prayed concerning those who were mine enemies, and thou didst turn them to me.
5 Yea, O God, and thou wast merciful unto me when I did cry unto thee in my field; when I did cry unto thee in my prayer, and thou didst hear me.
6 And again, O God, when I did turn to my house thou didst hear me in my prayer.
7 And when I did turn unto my closet, O Lord, and prayed unto thee, thou didst hear me.
@Jack, your example looks like some pretty heavy proof-texting.
For those who didn’t follow Jack’s argument, I believe he’s referring to Zenos’s prayer containing a progression of places where he prayed: wilderness -> field -> house -> closet. Read as a spatial progression from outermost to innermost, the argument (a very weak one, in my opinion) is that it parallels the movement through rooms in the modern LDS endowment: the wilderness as the lone and dreary world, the house as the temple, the closet as the holy of holies or celestial room, and so on. The “temple in the BoM” people take this kind of thing much further than Jack does here.
It’s the kind of stretching a person does when they believe the temple is a critical part of the “fulness of the gospel,” and since the BoM claims to contain the fulness of the gospel, the temple must be in there somewhere. When the temple doesn’t actually seem to be anywhere in the BoM, you start proof-texting to find it–and reaching for words like “palimpsest” to describe its faint presence.
Taking Jack’s quote in isolation, it’s already hard to get those verses to say anything resembling LDS temple ordinances. Read in context, it becomes obvious the chapter isn’t about the temple at all.
In Alma 33, Alma is teaching the Zoramite poor, who have been cast out of their synagogues, that they can worship God anywhere. Zenos’s prayer is invoked as a list of places where one can worship outside a church building: wilderness, field, house, closet. And if you keep reading, the spatial progression falls apart. After “closet” it goes to “congregations” and then to being “cast out and despised.” That’s a list of varied circumstances, not a graded ascent toward the innermost room of a temple.
Also, the word “closet” is almost certainly borrowed straight from the KJV and is clearly not an inner temple room. Compare Matthew 6:6:
“But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret; and thy Father which seeth in secret shall reward thee openly.”
to Alma 33:7-8 (Jack quoted verse 7 but stopped short of verse 8, where the borrowing becomes obvious):
“And when I did turn unto my closet, O Lord, and prayed unto thee, thou didst hear me. Yea, thou art merciful unto thy children when they cry unto thee, to be heard of thee and not of men, and thou wilt hear them.”
Matthew 6 contrasts private, sincere prayer with the public, theatrical prayers of hypocrites in synagogues and on street corners who wanted to be seen by others. The “closet” is a private space for personal prayer, not the inner sanctum of a temple. The BoM passage is making the same point.
I’m not finding a palimpsest here. Those who do find the LDS temple in these verses find it because their dogma needs it to be in the BoM somewhere.
mountainclimber479,
There’s no way that I can prove that Zenos is involking temple imagery. But in my estimation it follows a specific pattern that is common in temple liturgy. Of course it could be mere coincidence that the pattern appears as it does–but there it is. And it appears in other places in the BoM–and some of them are much more graphic and detailed than the one I shared from Alma 33. Lehi’s dream, for example, is a marvelous allegorical depiction of that pattern.
That said, I think it’s important to consider how the pattern of ascension corresponds to the *ancient* temple. The wilderness lies outside the holy precincts of temple. The field is the outer courtyard; the house the Holy Place; and the closet the Holy of Holies. And then when we’ve got that pattern laid out clearly we take it and measure it against the *narrative* of the modern endowment and we get a perfect fit.
If the pattern of ascension appears by chance in the BoM it’s only because it was deeply engrained in the religious culture of the Nephites. Even so, I’m of the opinion that the authors of the BoM knew exactly what they were doing when they wove those elements to the narrative.
@Jack,
Ascension is a core theme of nearly every religion, not at all a sure sign of temple liturgy. Muhammad’s night journey carries him up through seven heavens. Plato’s cave is an ascent out of darkness into sunlight. Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress sends Christian along a narrow path, past the mockers at Vanity Fair, and across a river to the Celestial City–and Bunyan was a Baptist with no temple at all. So of course a book presenting itself as ancient American Christianity talks about ascent. That tells us nothing about the endowment. Lehi’s dream is an ascension allegory, sure, but the closest known parallel to it is the dream Joseph Smith Sr. had around 1811, as Lucy Mack Smith recorded it: a barren field, a narrow path, a rope running alongside it, a tree with white fruit, a spacious building full of people mocking. No temple required to explain any of it.
As for the “perfect fit” with the modern endowment: a four-step outside-to-inside sequence fits a cathedral, a mosque, a courthouse, or a corporate office equally well. A pattern that generic fits everything, so a fit proves nothing.
Now to “the authors of the BoM knew exactly what they were doing.” Let’s test that against the Bible, which came out of the same tradition the Nephites left Jerusalem with. Bible writers were not coy about the temple or about what went on inside it. Exodus 28 describes the priestly garments down to the breastplate and the Urim and Thummim. Exodus 29 and Leviticus 8 walk through the washing, anointing, and clothing of priests. Exodus 30 describes the laver and the ritual washing before entering the Holy Place. Leviticus 16 lays out the Day of Atonement step by step, including the high priest passing through the veil into the Holy of Holies. These are the ancient temple ordinances, spelled out in a public text, in detail. If sacredness required secrecy, the writers of the Torah never got the memo.
And before you say the Nephites held a higher standard of secrecy than Moses: the modern church doesn’t hold that standard either. Its own website describes the endowment–washing and anointing, the garment, instruction on the creation and fall and atonement, and the covenants of obedience, sacrifice, the gospel, chastity, and consecration, by name. Members write books about the temple. Scholars like Stapley write histories of it. The only things kept out of public view are a handful of specific tokens, signs, and names. Everything else is openly discussed. So “sacred, therefore unmentionable” doesn’t describe the Bible, and it doesn’t describe modern LDS practice. There is no reason to think it described the Nephites.
Which brings us to the Nephites themselves. They weren’t shy about temples: Nephi says flatly that he built one “after the manner of the temple of Solomon” (2 Nephi 5:16), Jacob preaches at it, King Benjamin assembles the whole people at it, Christ appears at the one in Bountiful. They weren’t shy about ordinances either: Moroni 4-5 gives the sacrament prayers word for word, Moroni 2-3 describes conferring the Holy Ghost and ordaining priests, 3 Nephi 11 gives the baptismal formula verbatim. What never appears, anywhere, is a description of anything done inside a Nephite temple that resembles the endowment. So why would writers who print the sacrament prayers verbatim bury the endowment so deep inside a prayer about where God hears you that only modern temple-goers can find it? That makes no sense — and don’t tell me there wasn’t room on the plates. The book finds room for a page on Nephite weights and measures (Alma 11) and chapter after chapter of troop movements.
I maintain that your dogma regarding the temple is causing you to read things into the text that can’t be found there without a lot of imagination.
I think 3rd Nephi chapter 19 is a wonderful example of how the Book of Mormon sets forth the pattern of ascension in pretty straightforward terms.
It begins with the gathering of the people–and it speaks of the strenuous efforts they make to be there for the Savior’s return:
3 Yea, and even all the night it was noised abroad concerning Jesus; and insomuch did they send forth unto the people that there were many, yea, an exceedingly great number, did labor exceedingly all that night, that they might be on the morrow in the place where Jesus should show himself unto the multitude.
And when the people are gathered the disciples teach them the words of Jesus–and then they, the disciples, go down into the water and are baptized and receive the Holy Ghost:
13 And it came to pass when they were all baptized and had come up out of the water, the Holy Ghost did fall upon them, and they were filled with the Holy Ghost and with fire.
14 And behold, they were encircled about as if it were by fire; and it came down from heaven, and the multitude did witness it, and did bear record; and angels did come down out of heaven and did minister unto them.
And it is after they receive the Holy Ghost that the Savior appears to them:
15 And it came to pass that while the angels were ministering unto the disciples, behold, Jesus came and stood in the midst and ministered unto them.
The Savior commands the people to kneel down on the ground and pray. And as they pray he leaves them for a moment and prays to the Father in private, thanking him for giving the disciples the Holy Ghost–and prays that all else who believe their words might receive the Holy Ghost as well. And when he returns to the people we see a wonderful thing happening to the disciples. They are beginning to glow even like the Savior:
25 And it came to pass that Jesus blessed them as they did pray unto him; and his countenance did smile upon them, and the light of his countenance did shine upon them, and behold they were as white as the countenance and also the garments of Jesus; and behold the whiteness thereof did exceed all the whiteness, yea, even there could be nothing upon earth so white as the whiteness thereof.
And again the Savior removes himself from the people and prays in private–and he thanks the Father for purifying his disciples. And again he also prays that all who believe on their words may be purified as well. And after he checks on them he removes himself once more–but this time he prays to the Father in a heavenly language:
32 And tongue cannot speak the words which he prayed, neither can be written by man the words which he prayed.
33 And the multitude did hear and do bear record; and their hearts were open and they did understand in their hearts the words which he prayed.
34 Nevertheless, so great and marvelous were the words which he prayed that they cannot be written, neither can they be uttered by man.
I have to be careful now–because what we see here in this telling of the Savior’s visit follows the pattern of the endowment. There are five primary events that occur in the way that Mormon sets forth the marvelous visit of the Savior.
First, the struggle of the people to get to the place where the Savior was to appear.
Second, the preaching of the gospel followed by baptism and the reception of the Holy Ghost.
Third, the appearance of the Savior.
Fourth, the purification of the disciples.
Fifth, the Savior’s prayer to the father in a heavenly language that the people were able to understand in their hearts.
And so what we see is the people sacrificing their all to be there when the Savior arrives. But before the Savior appears they are taught the gospel of Christ. And after they are instructed and view the baptism of the disciples and their reception of the Holy Ghost–it is then that the Savior appears. And now, because they are in the presence of the Savior, it’s as if they’ve lifted into a higher and holier sphere-and it is there that the disciples become purified. And after they are purified they (and the multitude) are able to understand in their hearts the heavenly words that were spoken by the Savior–a powerful unifying experience for all who were there.
It is essential acts II and III of the endowment.
Once you come to the conclusion that it was all man-made and made up (the BOM, the P of GP, the JST, the temple ceremonies, the “priesthood”) it makes more sense. That’s my opinion of course. It answers a lot of questions.
The title of this post had me immediately thinking….did Joseph Smith invent a religion not just a temple ceremony.
I appreciate what mountainclimber479 writes. There is a pattern of ascension to God and it exists independent of the LDS Restoration. I believe Joseph Smith recognized this pattern and incorporated it into his writings. The Book of Mormon is replete with the pattern and the Books of Moses and Abraham (with Adam, Enoch & Abraham) exemplify the pattern.
It reasons that Joseph Smith would be attracted to the temple religion – for the temple is a symbol in the ascension pattern. But is the LDS temple THE ascension pattern? I don’t see it that way. That the “secrets” of the LDS temple have zero meaning outside the temple is a big clue of this. The temple ritual is a ritual in and of itself. It is a play (or at least once was presented as a play) that instructed on how we make our journey to God. This is fine and noteworthy. But I don’t see how the temple ritual has any significance outside of the temple. I’ve tried really hard to find the significance and I come up empty. I respect those who feel otherwise but I don’t find a higher purpose in the esoteric rituals of the temple endowment. They are part of the show (and the show changes, doesn’t it) and that’s fine with me.
Kudos to Rick Bennett for his podcasts and tackling these subjects and the audiences you entertain. Thank you, Rick!
Is this a trick question?
Jack,
I find it defies all logic for someone such as Nephi to preach about delighting in plainness and then bury temple ceremonies into text that requires the reader to squint and look sideways. We already know that the endowment came from a Scottish male fraternity. There is absolutely nothing ancient about it. JS was really good a riffing on things. That’s not to say he’s unique in that. I think most religious and human ritual is riffing on what came before. For some reason, though, we have a chain of custody obsession that no one else cares about.
@Jack,
3 Nephi 19 is a glorious chapter. It is not the endowment.
First, notice what your five-step pattern leaves out. The endowment is a ritual: washing, anointing, clothing in the garment, a creation-and-Eden drama with Adam and Eve and Satan, a set of named covenants, signs and tokens, and a veil. 3 Nephi 19 has none of those. No clothing, no Eden, no Adam, no Satan, no covenants (I repeat–no covenants–Russell Nelson would surely disagree with your interpretation without the covenants!), no veil, no building–they’re on a hillside. What it does have is people gathering, preaching, baptism, the Holy Ghost, Christ appearing, the disciples transfigured, and prayer. Strip the endowment of everything that makes it the endowment and keep only “people gather, learn, are purified, enter God’s presence, and pray,” and sure, 3 Nephi 19 fits. So does every revival meeting in the Burned-over District in 1820.
Let’s apply your method to Kirtland in 1836. The Saints sacrificed everything to build a temple and gather to it. They were washed and anointed. At the dedication and in the days after, people reported angels, pillars of fire, speaking in tongues, and Christ appearing in the temple. That is a better match for your five steps than 3 Nephi 19 is, and it has the washing, the anointing, the veil, and the temple building that 3 Nephi 19 lacks. And yet it is not the endowment you’re talking about. The Nauvoo endowment–the acts II and III you’re invoking–did not exist until May 1842. If your pattern identifies Kirtland 1836 as the endowment, your pattern is identifying the wrong thing.
You still haven’t answered the question from my last comment. The OT describes washing, anointing, clothing, and the high priest passing through the veil, in public and in detail. The modern church describes the endowment’s structure and covenants on its own website. Nephite writers printed the sacrament prayers word for word. So why would those same writers hide the endowment so well that most of their faithful modern readers can’t find it, in a chapter where they openly describe baptism and the gift of the Holy Ghost? You keep offering new passages. The passages aren’t the problem. The method is.
mountainclimber479,
3 Nephi 19 moves through the sequence of the endowment without the trappings of ritual–that’s the beauty of it. And so it gives us some important clues as to what it is that the endowment portrays by means of its forms. Indeed, there are elements in the 3rd Nephi narrative that are too sacred to speak of–and yet they are set forth in plainness.
And on top of that, the event also coincides well with the meaning of the ancient temple–such as the constant prayer of the people. The altar of incense is placed just before the great veil in the Holy Place–and it is known to represent the prayers of the saints. And it’s interesting to note that that particular element is represented in the exact same position–in terms of the narrative–in modern temple liturgy.
And another important event that should be mentioned (IMO) is the sacrament that the Savior provides to the people after the purification of the disciples. In this instance the Lord utilizes it as ritual inauguration of the people into the divine council. This is what he means when he tells his disciples (in the Bible) that he will partake of it again with them in the Kingdom of Heaven.
As to your question: The Book of Mormon tells the reader in numerous places that it is a lesser portion of the word. And so it is not going to reveal the sacred elements of the “greater portion” of the word–though (IMO) the reader may infer the mysteries in many instances. But it does suggest that the individual can receive the greater portion through direct revelation. And today, with the added help of modern temple liturgy, the saints can receive the ordinances of the temple and then approach the Lord with specific questions as to their meaning. It is a marvelous blessing.
chrisdrobison,
As I said to mountainclimber479, the Book of Mormon was compiled as a “lesser portion” of the word. Indeed, in 3 Nephi 26 Mormon said that he was about to write all the word of the Savior–but the Lord forbade him saying, “I will try the faith of my people.” Even so, Nephi (in 1 Nephi 10) tells us explicitly that we may learn the mysteries through the manifestations of the Holy Ghost.
@Jack, I think you are reading far too much into the text than is actually there. The “forms” that you identify are so vague and general that it is impossible to identify an endowment ceremony going on in 3 Nephi 19. The straightforward reading of the chapter is simply a glorious visitation from Christ–not a temple ceremony. You can wave your hands as much as you want with any of the 3 examples you’ve provided, but I don’t think you’re going to convince me–or most faithful Mormons, for that matter–that these BoM passages are referring to the temple endowment.
Even if we were to assume this chapter is presenting an endowment ceremony, then why don’t we find a single mention of the “normal” day-to-day endowment performed in Nephite temples–you know the way it would be done for the remaining 1000 years of BoM history where Jesus Christ wasn’t physically present with them? The BoM doesn’t have to reveal anything too secret/sacred to mention an endowment-like temple ordinance. Like I’ve said already, both the OT and today’s Church talk quite openly about temple practices without revealing the most secret parts. If the Nephites had any sort of similar ordinance, I would expect the BoM to mention it in quite plain terms just as it does with other ordinances like baptism or the sacrament. It simply doesn’t. Neither does the Bible.
The endowment is new–it’s first enactment on planet earth was in the upper room of the red brick store in 1842 Nauvoo. Yes, there are Mormons who find the endowment in both the BoM and the Bible. They find it there because their belief system requires it to be there. Unfortunately for them, it really isn’t there.
Church leaders would love nothing more than to be able to connect ancient temple worship in the New World or the Old World to the modern LDS temple. This is very rarely attempted in official Church publications. And, when it is mentioned, it’s typically just some very basic hand waving along the lines of, “We needed the Restoration to recover sacred temple ordinaces.” or “The temple ordinances are ancient in origin.” They largely just stop at that. Why? Because temple worship of ancient Israel as found in the Bible bears very little resemblance to modern LDS temple worship, and the temple worship in the BoM really isn’t elaborated on at all, so most faithful Mormons conclude it was the same as the Jewish temple in the Old World. If the link between the modern endowment and ancient Jewish temple worship was obvious, we would hear it nonstop in GC talks (and such mentions wouldn’t need to reveal ny of the temple “secrets”). It isn’t, so we don’t.
Finally, I would suggest that this topic is a good example of Mormon apologetics that likely does more harm than good. There are questioning Church members out there who wonder why, if the endowment is required for exaltation, it isn’t found anywhere in ancient scripture. It’s a good, valid question. They go digging for answers, discover the writings of Mormon apologists who distort the text of the Bible/BoM to find the endowment there, find the apologetic arguments very bad and unconvincing, and become disillusioned. It would be better for the Church to simply say something along the lines of, “The modern endowment was revealed for the first time in 1842, and for reasons known only to God, it is a modern-only ordinance that wasn’t practiced by Biblical or BoM peoples.” It’s still not a great answer, but it’s a whole lot better to be straightforward and honest than to provide apologetic arguments that twist the scriptures to the point that most people just aren’t going to be able to accept.
Jack,
“he was about to write all the word of the Savior–but the Lord forbade him saying, “I will try the faith of my people.” ”
I find that a convenient cop-out. It is a strategy I’ve seen from others in our modern day claiming secret divine knowledge. Same game, different players. What faith is being tried? It’s not, it’s just stupid carrot dangling and a loyalty test. It has human invention written all over it. That is a game I’m no longer interested in playing. We’ve done far better as a species following the scientific method than we ever have under all religions combined over the last many thousands of years. God’s “secret knowledge” might have convinced a lot more a long time ago to seek after it, but it holds mostly no interest for people today–and rightly so. Secret knowledge is a means to control and manipulate people into doing what you want them to do, not enriching their lives and the lives of those around them.
Just be clear: I’m not suggesting that the endowment as we know it today is found in the Book of Mormon in exact detail. I’m saying that a pattern of ascension that is similar to what we see in the modern temple is found all over the BoM. And it’s because such a pattern is so ubiquitous in the text that we can surmise that its writers were undoubtably familiar with the mysteries. And again, I’m not suggesting that the mysteries must look exactly the way they do in our temples today. But even so, the similar patterns cannot be dismissed without doing a the restoration a great disservice. Because with hindsight it’s plain to see why our temple theology should follow the same sequence as is found in the Book of Mormon–and, indeed, the entire canon.
@Jack, as I’ve mentioned before, that pattern of ascension is too vague and universal throughout all of Christianity and, indeed, all major world religions, to conclude that the BoM “writers were undoubtably familiar with the mysteries”. We find it in the Koran, we find it in Plato’s writings, we find it in Pilgrim’s Progress, we find it in the vision of Joseph Smith, Sr. that is so remarkably similar to Lehi’s dream in the BoM, we find it everywhere. The presence of ascension in any given narrative–BoM or not–is not sufficient to conclude that the author is “familiar with the mysteries”. You are going beyond what the text actually says because your dogma really wants it to be there.
Thanks for engaging with me, mountainclimber479–but at this point we’ll have to agree to disagree. IMO, the elements of the patterns in the BoM are too specific for them to be no more than an echo of transmitted beliefs across time and culture.
It’s not unknown what went on in the Second Temple that was still standing in Jerusalem when Jesus was alive. And it wasn’t handshakes, skits relating to the Earth’s creation, secret passwords, or marriages.
Jonathan N,
The ordinances and activities that were performed in the Second Temple were forms that served the purposes of the lesser priesthood.