As a people, one thing we definitely do is sing. We may not sing well, we often don’t, but every Sunday, rain or shine, we file into those pews and we sing. As many as four different times.
And if you’re a child? More singing!
Like nearly everybody else [1], we’re singing less than we used to, but still we sing. Inwardly kicking and screaming, maybe. Against our better judgment and in spite of being bored to tears, we sing.
Music has probably been a feature of worship since humans started the practice. There’s a reason the Psalms are among the most quoted scriptures.
And yet, as things stand, we’ve managed to take the life right out of singing. And I know; this isn’t a uniquely Mormon problem. It’s just that we’ve done an especially excellent job of making communal singing a joyless penance.
It is a sorry state of affairs.
Last Sunday, I participated in our ward’s Primary Program. Both of my kids are still in Primary (this is the eldest’s last Program—she’d be elated if she could find it in her to care about anything church-related). One of my kids sings beautifully; one can’t carry a tune in a bucket, and they both hate it. In elementary school, they each had about two years of mandatory choral ensemble, which is more than many public school kids get, and they hated that too.
Why do we hate singing? A few of the very youngest kids in our Primary were really into it, belting the words for all to hear. And we have one child who has the makings of a truly gifted singer. But most were in it for the celebratory ice cream sundae party in the second hour (it was awesome—wish you were there).
In general, singing isn’t cool. Church has made it a chore, and communal singing is all but gone from our wider culture.
Maybe I’m a weirdo, but I really enjoy singing. I’m not especially good. But I’m not bad either. And just about the only time it’s ever okay to sing communally these days outside of church is “Happy Birthday to You.” While I’m carrying the melody, everybody else looks like they have a toothache. And they look faintly embarrassed for me, I’m so clearly into it.
And before you tell me that there are places for deviants like me called community choirs, 1) I know, 2) it figures prominently in my retirement plan, 3) that’s not what I want; or rather, it’s not all I want. I want us to sing together in public and enjoy it. I want for it not to matter how good or bad we are. The point is we’re doing it together and having a good time.
One of the problems, of course, is that all of us have access, all the time, to exceptional singing. You pull out your smartphone and the best singers ever recorded are all right there for you to enjoy. The best choirs too. MoTab—sorry, the Tabernacle Choir at Temple Square (I’ve died inside), the Vienna Boys’ Choir, the San Francisco Gay Men’s Chorus, the Choir of King’s College, Cambridge. “What’s the point?” we grumble. “We’re never gonna sound like that.”
But that’s just it. The point isn’t being exceptional! The point is being together. We’ve lost the art of being unexceptional together. Lost our patience for it too.
Not me. I have faith in our ordinariness, in the power of our mediocrity. I have seen what happens when people find connection through singing together. A couple of examples:
- On an overnight field trip with a group of students, the entire busload of us spontaneously burst into a rendition of Sublime’s Santeria. (My students were both surprised and impressed that I knew every word.) It was a trip highlight for all of us and remains one of my fondest career memories.
- When I taught the British literature series at my college, Robbie Burns came up in the lineup right around Burns’ Night. We’d turn class into a Burns’ morning, and I compelled every class to sing “Auld Lang Syne” (all five verses). They’d roll their eyes at first, and invariably, by the end of the song, people were holding hands and crying.
The holiday season is coming, and it’s another one of those vanishingly rare times when maybe, just maybe, you’ll get the chance to sing communally in public. Maybe even outside of a religious setting.
I have a request: Do it!
Some questions:
- What do you think accounts for the disappearance of communal singing in public life?
- What would make singing in church better?
- When was the last time you enjoyed singing in a group in public?
[1] And it’s only gotten worse in the nearly 15 years since that article was published.

Music is what helped me hold on to church attendance the longest.
The vast majority of the profound spiritual experiences I’ve had in my life happened while I was singing. I enjoyed singing the hymns in Sacrament Meeting, especially when the organist went “rogue” and actually played at tempo rather than lapsing into the habit of converting each hymn into a dirge. The only calling I ever enjoyed was playing piano for the primary. Listening to kids sing with enthusiasm and utter conviction was inspiring. Even if not all were participating equally, it was overall a joyful noise.
Sure, I’m biased in favor of singing. Of music in general, really. Once I hit puberty and my voice changed, I joined the ward choir. I successfully auditioned for the elite choir in high school. On my mission there was a quartet of us that, whenever we saw each other at leadership meetings, would sing together a cappella during breaks. In college I joined the institute’s audition choir. During winter and spring breaks we would tour various seminaries in the area. Singing and having spiritual experiences all day, every day, for a week was exhausting, but uplifting. More recently I joined a gay men’s chorus, as a straight man. They welcomed me wholeheartedly and I got to sing challenging and fun songs. I’m confident in my choir voice. At some point I’d like to take voice lessons and improve my ability to sing solos.
Singing Happy Birthday never goes well. Even in the institute choir when we’d sing for member birthdays we managed to fail somehow.
I think singing in church would go better if the hymns were played at the proper speed, for one thing. I think hymn selection plays a big part, too. While it is important to remain “on theme” for the meeting, selecting hymns that people like to sing (and are able to sing) would invite more to participate. I also think that those who have developed their vocal talents should maybe hold back a little bit. I recognize that I hearing a trained singer can be intimidating, so when I sing hymns I don’t go all out. I love singing and I want others to enjoy it too.
Love this Margie! I love to sing, though I’m okay at it, I can carry a tune, I’m no pro. I loved sitting next to a dear friend over the last 5 years that could carry a tune and sing parts. When he would sing the parts, I could follow the notes and sing with him. It was one aspect of that calling that I shall cherish. My dogs get sung to on a regular basis. Especially when arriving home from church, I sing made up songs of my joy that they are part of our family, usually to the tune of a hymn sung in church…..”I thank thee oh god for my dogalini’s, they sure like to wag their tails alot!”
When I was a wee lad, my dad used to play guitar, banjo or ukelele and we would sing fun songs like “Little Brown Jug” “Fox Went Out on a Chilly Night.” On warm summer days there was always music in our home when we swam in our pool, Sergio Mendes and the Brazil 66, Herb Alpert, Baja Marimba Band, Mamas & the Papas, Elton John, Beatles.
My dear Mother in law played piano and organ in our congregation and on a regular basis, the sweet lady that was our chorister would start to lead a beautiful hymn like it was a funeral dirge and my Mother in law would pick up the speed to a point that you think her old lady triceps were going to swing right off her arm!🤣
I think there is a move afoot with some of new hymns coming out to “pep up” our singing in church. I certainly hope so.
Cheers to making up “Dog Songs”😉
I love this! Music has always been my surest route to a connection to the Divine.
Singing with the Tabernacle Choir has been one of the great joys of my life for that very reason. However, as the OP points out, you don’t have to sound like the TabCATS (the replacement acronym for MoTab) to create that connection. I’ve felt it in ward choirs or barbershop quartets or even karaoke. There’s something profoundly unifying about music, especially when everyone is singing along, and it has nothing to do with talent or technical skill.
I remember the first time I sat in a sacrament meeting alongside my father-in-law. He sang the opening hymn with gusto, and I was perplexed as, looking at the hymnbook, I couldn’t tell if he was singing the tenor or the bass part. It finally dawned on me that he was singing the melody – or trying to, anyway. It made absolutely no difference to him that he couldn’t carry a tune even if it had handles on it. He was making a joyful noise, and it was extraordinarily endearing. It was also very much a fulfillment of D&C 25:12 – “[T]he song of the righteous is a prayer unto me, and it shall be answered with a blessing upon their heads.”
As my father always used to say, there isn’t a meeting in the Church that couldn’t be improved by better music, and more of it, and better speaking, and less of it.
Stallioncornell – Your father nailed it! A great friend that was on my flight crew for numerous combat missions is not a member, does not attend a church, but considers “Music and the Spoken Word” his worship time on Sundays.
Keep up the good work brother of the TabCats, I love that!
These posts always engender extremely mixed emotions for me.
I love music. I think it’s an integral part of worship. I mourn the loss of music in our worship services.
But…
Can we please quit ragging on the organists? From personal experience, I can assure you that most of us are doing the best we can. I love music, but I’m a poor musician. I genuinely can’t carry a tune. After years of training, I can tell when I’m not on pitch, but I can’t tell if it’s sharp or flat so I can’t fix it. I have had years of lessons on multiple instruments, and I’m not good at playing any of them. I compensate for lack of ability with years of lessons and hours of daily practice. Those years of lessons were all at my own expense. There’s no institutional support for any of this.
I don’t know who will replace me when I can no longer fill the calling. Playing the piano does NOT mean you can play the organ. It means you can learn to play the organ if you’re willing to put in the work. More, if you do learn to play the organ, you will never have another calling because there won’t be anyone to replace you either. For some people, that’s a good prospect. For many of us, it’s a loss. I love music, but it’s not all I am.
This came out angrier than I expected. But I’m doing the best I can. If you don’t like it, you are welcome to replace me yourself.
I need to add that the same is true for choristers. My current chorister can’t even read music. Trying to help her learn how to lead Gethsemane was huge. I admire her dedication to serving wherever she is called!
Hi Everybody!
AdamL, wow! Your ability far eclipses my own. I can sing the alto part only on songs I know really well, and learning a new part can take me a lonnnng time. It is a good note on trying to sing things a bit faster–as a barely passable (on a good day) organist, I struggle with that one, but I do try to pick up the tempo when I can. It does help!
17Rider, I characterize my own ability as a singer as right about where you are. I can do the melody and usually do it justice. Beyond that, I better have a lot of practice. I have tried to train my ear to do better, but so much of whether or not you’re going to be good at music seems innate to me. And this is a decade of childhood piano lessons plus countless hours of lifetime practice talking here. In a way it’s been good for me to work so hard at something for such poor-to-mediocre results. Makes me less vain about the things I am pretty good at: I got genetically lucky.
stallioncornell: As an aspiring crazy-cat-lady, I suppose I can get behind the TabCATS. And wow, congratulations! When I was in grad school our administrative professional and her husband (who was on the faculty) both sang with the choir, and holy smokes were they talented. She led our annual holiday sing along, and she once did a parody of how we all sounded–to hear a truly gifted singer impersonate terrible singing–oh! it was a treat. Congrats on your spot in the choir! That is a serious musical accomplishment!
PWS, Solidarity. I am the only organist in my ward, and it frequently makes me sorry for everyone. So yeah. Every Sunday (that I’m in town), it’s me up there. And while I love music, it is not a very innate talent for me either. Sometimes “funerary march” is the only speed at which I can legitimately play a hymn. But I figure they’re listen and they’ll like it, dammit. lol. And also, yes to the poor choristers. They are doing their best!
A cousin of mine is very in to Sacred Harp singing. I went to his wedding recently, it was wonderful! They both had friends and family filling this big, old building, singing these old, mostly gospel related songs. I wasn’t there for much of the singing, just enough to get a taste. The wedding was so much fun, more fun that I think I’ve ever had at a wedding (I almost said outside of my own, but, the actual wedding part, while beautiful and deeply meaningful to me, I wouldn’t really describe as fun.) There were all kinds of wonderfully strange people there. The wedding was officiated by a non-gender conforming person (I hate to use a euphemism, but I’m not sure if they were transgender or just in drag) who had introduced the happy couple to each other. My very-Mormon relatives seemed to support their son through it all, despite their apparent discomfort with the non-traditional setting. At one point, I ran into my uncle, father-of-the-groom, an old, serious, Mormon, cowboy, who muttered to me, with some exasperation, that there was a lot more silliness at the wedding than he was accustomed to seeing. I laughed and responded that they had done it there way hadn’t they. He reflected for a moment and said “well, there’s a lot more love here too.”
I guess I should clarify that I’m not ragging on the organists. When the entire congregation is used to singing at a slower tempo and you’re trying to play at the correct tempo it feels like trying to run a race wearing an enormous weight around your body. It’s exhausting. Especially when the chorister is trying to direct at the usual, slow tempo. Once everyone catches on and is willing to move at the same pace it’s easier. I wrote about the organist specifically because, in my experience, the congregation will follow the organist over the chorister. Partially because learning to follow music direction is a learned skill, just as accompanying and directing music are learned skills.
On a different note, I wanted to touch on Margie’s mention of Robert Burns music. I got a chance several years ago to do some work with the archival collection of Serge Hovey, who worked with Jean Redpath to research and record the music that Robert Burns collected and wrote down. In some cases, this involved Hovey filling in some musical gaps in the music. Most of my work with the collection was scanning in the songs and sending them to a group in Scotland that was working on a musical production of Burns’ work. It was when I learned that Burns had traveled extensively across Scotland to collect folk song in order to write them down and preserve them in a manner more lasting than the oral tradition. Fascinating collection.
I’m not sure I agree that we’ve lost communal singing, at least in an appreciable way over the last several generations. I’m 44 years old. Outside of church, what communal singing have I done in my adult life? Happy Birthday and Take Me Out to the Ball Game (I attend roughly 0.5 baseball games per year) are about it. And my parents? I can’t think of a time that my parents sang communally in my entire life. And my grandparents? I experienced less of their lives, but I don’t know in what setting they were singing communally as adults outside of church. So maybe we all sat around the wood stove and sang communally at some point, but who was doing that in the last 100 years? Fewer community choirs exist today than in the past (probably, adjusted for population) but those participants were always in the minority. I’m failing to see where the drop off in adult communal singing is coming from beyond a drop in singing in church.
As for improving singing in church, I have all sorts of ideas:
1: Remove the last 8 rows of folding chairs from the back. People don’t sing because they can’t hear anyone else singing because every sits so far apart from each other. Getting as many people as possible out of the basketball court and into the chapel would improve the acoustics dramatically.
2: Pick decent songs. Why does my ward keep singing songs about going to sleep at noon in sacrament meeting?
3: Release the dang hymn book already. In an effort to simplify the hymnal, we have over the course of years released about 100 new songs while removing none. Why is this thing a 3 year roll out?
4: Provide resources for organists. You know what gets people to sing? Jazzed up introductions to hymns. Fancy interludes between verses. Key changes. I have a few I’ve scrounged from the internet or from a self-published booklet from my wife’s aunt’s friend. The church could absolutely be publishing this stuff, for free, for every organist to use as they are able. They could produce books and books of music for organists to use to add spice and variety. Easy versions, fancy versions. Some of us have the ability to play more interesting notes, but aren’t sure which ones to hit.
5: Grant access to the organ to every person in the ward who can play the organ. If you’re not regularly playing the organ, your skills are degrading. And for the vast majority of organists, the only organ we can hope to play on is locked up in the church. If I’m released from my calling as organist, the church expects to be able to come back to me in three years and have me start playing again, when I have no ability to practice in between. Yes, playing the piano helps, but it does not replace playing on a real organ. (Even as the organist I’ve had to spend *months* asking for access to the organ.) Real organ access, not “you can come when someone else is already in the building” access. My schedule doesn’t work that way.
6: Cultivate musicians. When I was a kid, it seemed that every Mormon kid learned to play the piano. This is definitely less true today. And those that take lessons are less proficient than they used to be. (More competing opportunities. And I’m glad that teenage girls can now chose to be on the high school mountain biking team. But it is eroding our base of talent for music.) Every good organist in the church exists because they took it upon themselves to seek out that skill. If we want more organists and better organists we need to remove barriers for people that want to do it. The church could pay people to give organ lessons. I’d do it. I have taught organ lessons, and I didn’t charge an arm and a leg. But I’m not going to do it for free.
Absolutely in favour of singing hymns enthusiastically and at a good tempo. Congregational singing is an important part of collective worship, and it drives me wild when verses or whole hymns are cut from the programme because speakers are taking too long, or the meeting started late.
AdamL, I’d disagree that asking the better singers to tone it down would be helpful. There’s a ward in my stake with a lot of great musicians, but their singing in sacrament meeting has been dire whenever I’ve visited, because presumably they’re toning it down. If the people who can sing don’t sing up, how is that helping those who cannot sing so well to sing up? They might be more enthusiastic if they felt the better singers were covering them somewhat.
Unfortunately there has for some time been a church culture of “reverence” in singing which appears to have meant slow and not enthusiastic. A former stake music chairman has a piece published in Dialogue several decades ago now, alluding to this. I still find the TabCATS or be painfully slow for some hymns in general conference. There was in the past a conference talk about ‘not making a show’ of oneself, or something. Surely that is more an inner state of mind. Are we singing with our whole souls in worship, for God, in which case stop worrying about it, or are we so concerned about not making a show that our singing is some mealy-mouthed trying not to perform performance?
Here in the UK, not only do we get to sing in church, but also in daily school assemblies. I came to love a lot of Anglican hymns that way, and now have quite a collection of different hymn books sat on the piano that I love to play from. One of my kids reported back when they were still in school, at a school camp one evening they all broke out into spontaneous singing of Jerusalem (regarded by students as the school hymn, though it is a well loved national hymn also). This is perhaps one reason why British football fans will also fill stadia with their singing of team songs.
I still love that Elder Christofferson in the video on using the new hymns, commented on how Elder Kearon is such an enthusiastic singer of the hymns in their meetings.
As a life long singer, loads of thoughts:
Singing at church is worship. It’s not therefore hard to look around the congregation and see who is interested in worshiping and who isn’t. Too harsh?
And. It’s too much singing for kids. Primary songs mostly suck.
Lifelong piano player. Given about 20 minutes of organ training. Hate playing the organ more than going to the dentist. If I could go back in time, I should have just played the piano.
I hate slow songs. I try to play fast. But because I don’t know how to play the organ, it’s possible I wasn’t playing as fast as I thought I was. It’s just a lose-lose.
Every single chorister I worked with was incredible. I told them they had to follow me as I don’t play the organ and therefore don’t have the capacity to follow them because just playing the organ was hard enough. They played ball. A few even just let me pick the songs so I could play easier stuff.
I’ve visited a few other churches in my life and while I’ve never been to one with a full blown gospel choir because I don’t live in Alabama, their congregation singing was ALL superior to what I hear in a Mormon sacrament meeting. YMMV.
We had mandatory singing and recorder classes in elementary school in Utah in the 80s. My kids get music lessons in school in California that include a choice of choir, strings, or wind instruments. You really don’t learn much that way but it’s something. I think music appreciation matters. Where I think we fail is when the people tasked with teaching young people insist on teaching them something instead of helping them have an enjoyable experience. Want to turn a nine year old off to music? Make them play some Mozart song terribly. Heaven forbid maybe they learn something from Dua Lipa instead. In crocs. With hot dogs. Or to my earlier point, Primary music sucks, so kids learn to hate singing, and they never get over it as adults. And round and round we go.
AdamL, I think having to drag the congregation along with the chorister and organist might also be a matter of physics. Sound waves travel relatively slowly. By the time my music reaches the back of the cultural hall, the congregation is already behind me on the notes. By the time the singing gets back up to me, I’m quite a ways ahead of the singing. Organists kind of have to learn to ignore the singing, and just play. I don’t know that is the case, but I do know that trying to play along with the congregation is generally a disaster.
On a lighter note, one of my favorite memories is the one time I played hymn 1, The Morning Breaks, in Sacrament Meeting. The second line is men only. First verse–the only sound in the entire chapel was my playing. Not a single singer. By the 5th verse (!), there were a few brave souls singing. For some reason, we have never sung that song since. LOL
I used to love singing. But I got some sort of virus lodged in my vocal chords and it has been difficult to sing in a sustained way. I can now sing about a two-octave vocal range for no longer than 20 minutes at a time. I used to be close to 3 octaves. Not operatic, belle canto style, but rock/pop style.
Singing in choirs actually isn’t much my thing. I prefer to sing solo with a guitar. Also I prefer rock singing. For a while I worked on having grittier vocals. That said, I don’t really have suggestions for communal church singing. Gospel rock? No thank you.
I will say that I remember growing up in Provo and going to BYU the community was full of divas. I took singing lessons for about 2 months with a lady who used to sing in MoTab. I told her that I aspired to do rock singing. She was clueless as to what that was. She knew only church, classical, and Broadway. None of those styles appealed to me. I lasted a few lessons and had enough with her.
I have always loved music and started life as an instrumentalist (piano and strings), but I didn’t think I liked singing. In the MTC, the weekly choir practice was announced and my companion informed me we were going. I went along and discovered I liked it more than I thought. I have some great memories of singing on my mission. After my mission I decided to join an audition choir and made it in. Someone else who made it in that day didn’t have a car and needed a ride to rehearsals. She joined our carpool. Long story short, it took me 2 years of carpooling before I asked her out, but we’ve been married long enough now to have adult children, and needless to say I’m glad to have joined that choir.
As a parent of a kid who’s a serious soccer player and pro soccer fan, I’ve become aware that there’s a lot of singing at soccer games across the pond in the UK, which is fascinating to me. I don’t think we have anything close to that in our sports culture over here, except maybe singing the school fight song at college football games, but their songs seem to be far more varied. So maybe the decline in public singing is only an American phenomenon? I do agree with DaveW in questioning the premise that things were much different in the past.
For me, singing in church is more fun when good hymns are selected. Some just don’t work well. Almost every hymn tune arranged by J. S. Bach or Ralph Vaughan Williams is great for singing. It’s a great loss that each composer has only 1 hymn in our hymn book. If I were on the committee for the new hymn book, I would see to it that this egregious omission is corrected. I am concerned after singing some of the new hymns that not all of them are very easy to sing. I know they are trying to add more stylistic variation, but some of them may end up being quickly forgotten. Also, a good organist can make the singing more lively. But we’re a church of volunteers, so we take what we get.
I cannot speak for all of the 4000-series new hymns, but those we have sung have, for the most part, been abysmal failures in my opinion. They may have been written by people with degrees in music, but they do not bring the spirit, at least not to me. I have an idea of a reason, although I have not studied it all the way out. I love hymns of praise focused on God. Praiseful lyrics tied with praiseful music makes for a joyful common singing experience. But hymns focused on me as the singer, telling me how I should feel, and hymns that try to be sweet or spiritual with slow music and words focused on me (as to being focused on God) don’t make for a powerful singing experience. We should remember that hymn singing is not a world-wide common practice. The Catholics and Orthodox don’t have our hymn singing traditions, as these were made popular by Martin Luther. People of other faiths and cultures don’t have a congregational hymn-singing history. We have made this part of our worship experience because it was part of the worship experience of all those who joined the church in early days: most came from Protestant faith groups with strong hymn singing traditions. But this tradition is foreign in Japan, Cambodia, Ghana (except among Protestants there), and even Catholic countries like in South America. Is hymn singing really part of the gospel itself, a core part, or is this something that is American, Western European, and Protestant? Should it be central part of our divine services? I think it adds a lot, but a lot of the more modern LDS hymns don’t make the cut, in my non-trained ears to my non-educated mind. Many hymns might contain beautiful words and even beautiful music, but congregational hymn singing requires more. I think that more focus on praise, and less on self, and an upbeat tempo go a long way. The choirs at the last General Conference seemed to work hard to sing the slowest hymns possible, and I did not find it uplifting and engaging. Others may have loved it.
When I lived in Alaska, my ward had five organists. The first Sunday of the month was mine.
I travel a lot. In many branches in far-away places, the electronic piano is played by an American sister missionary. I am grateful for them, but I think the number of American sister missionaries who play the piano is going down over time. Many of my travels are for extended periods in places with Orthodox traditions, and there is no congregational singing in Orthodox traditions.
There is less communal singing today, compared to the old days, primarily I think because of the ubiquitous presence of recorded music — in the old days, if you wanted music, you had to make it yourself. But I think there is also another reason, related to the first, and that is that parents don’t sing with their children as much as they used to (and similarly, they also don’t read with them, either). I say this as an observation, not as a criticism.
Like some others in this thread, I wish we would sing more of the favorite hymns in our sacrament meetings. In my ward in the southern U.S. (I am recovering from injuries overseas), we don’t do rest hymns, and it seems that at least two, and sometimes all three, of the hymns are from the new four-digit selections. But if I may be honest, many if these are simply not suited to congregational singing. But even if we do sing something from the regular hymnal, it will be an obscure hymn.
I also agree with others in this thread who say the organ must lead the singing, and not follow the congregation or the chorister. The organ leads, and the chorister follows.
Looks like the next batch of new hymns just dropped. Fewer this time, but a couple more that were on my lengthy list of suggestions of great hymns that should be included.
It’s late at night here now, so I’ll wait until tomorrow to print off the new compositions and play through them. I hope they’re better than some of the other original compositions.
Once upon a time, in a land far far away, primary was held on Wednesday afternoon, and this time of year the children were happily singing, “One little, two little three little witches, flying over houses flying over ditches….” It was FUN, because the songs were fun songs and we were not expected to sit quietly and reverently. THAT was for Sunday. Then on Sunday we had Sunday school with song practice where the whole point was learning a new song. Sure the chorister was this semi literate old lady who could read on a second grade level and sometimes she got things very wrong and it was kind of funny to us rude, smarty pants teenagers, because really, the lady was uneducated. But, she did help us learn the songs because if she caught you not singing, she made you come up front where the whole ward watched to make sure you were trying to sing. As musical number is Sacrament meetings, Brother Robertson would play sax, or Sister Smith played guitar while her husband sang, because there were no “irreverent” instruments. brother Bowen played Mozart as prelude and Bach for postlude music.
Then the block schedule put primary on Sunday, and instead of being fun, it had to be reverent. No more singing about witches for Halloween or Santa for Christmas, but sing “reverently”. Then Packer got snitty about how some instruments were not proper for worship and how we all had to sing familiar songs, and even the prelude music had to be out of the approved hymn book. Boooorrrrriiiiinnnnnggggg.
My husband used to sing with a group that went around to different wards to perform for their sacrament meetings. Then the church said no more. He used to sing in pageants and plays sponsored by the stake. But that has gone the way of the dodo bird and passenger pigeon, as in killed by humans who cannot see beyond the current moment and have no idea what they are losing.
And then years later, people were discussing why people hate to sing and what is wrong with the music in church.
And my husband just left for ward choir practice, and will come home complaining.
ji and georgis, if I am recalling my research correctly, for a sacrament meeting talk I gave more than 10 years ago, the time of the great awakening, whether to sing hymns or not to sing hymns was one of the arguments going on. Some of the Methodist groups (surprisingly) and of course quakers, were opposed to hymn singing. The revelation to Emma Smith to compile a hymn book brought the early church down on the hymn singing side of the argument.
Quentin, I think quite a few of the English folk tunes used for hymns, are Vaughan-Williams arrangements, but I think they haven’t aged out of IP rights yet, so would have been excluded from consideration on that basis in the update, so I gather. We have music for both hymns 15 and 284 from V-W in the green hymn book. Though in the UK the tune for 15 is commonly used for the carol O little town of Bethlehem, so perhaps the British cultural preference for jollier tunes versus sweet contemplative ones is a wider UK v US difference, not just an LDS church thing.
And yes, whoever it was who wished they’d stuck to piano, that’s exactly what I do when I am required to accompany for sacrament meeting. Upbeat tempo over instrument every time. My sister manages the organ okay, but I never really got to grips with it.
Regarding Vaughan Williams hymn arrangements and copyright, I once looked into this and discovered that his hymn arrangements were published in 1906. To me that suggests it should all be public domain now, yet in the digital hymns, All Creatures Of Our God and King still has copyright license notices at the bottom of it. If anyone can shed light on why that is, I’d love to know. I find this a little confusing. Also, while on one level I can understand why the church would like to avoid copyright complications for their hymnbook, I’m pretty sure they could find the money for licensing fees if they wanted a particular hymn badly enough. Just saying.
Quentin, V-W not yet public domain the UK or the EU, where the law is different to the US. We have to wait until the end of 2028. It’s 70 years after the death (1958). Of course, the church could arrange licensing if they really wanted to, but the culture has certainly changed for the worse from a willingness to spend money since 1985.
Looks like All Creatures of our God and King in the hymn book is also the specific V-W arrangement. I didn’t realise that was one of his, so comes under that restriction in the UK and EU. I guess they feel that the global website needs to reflect that.
Hymnary.org is a good resource for anyone interested in hymns generally.
Like many of you, I agree that a lot of the problems with communal singing in the Church can be fixed by playing/singing the hymns at the indicated tempo, and maintaining it to the last note. That, of course, requires a little bit more conscious effort from the music leaders and organists. The conductor’s job is not only to set the pace to follow, but also set the enthusiasm level for the song. Most choristers in church today are reluctant volunteers who have no idea what they are doing, idly waving their hands, following the congregation and not the other way around as they should. In the ward where I grew up, the congregagtional hymn singing was led by an older gentleman, who despite being warm and friendly on a personal level, took the music absolutely seriously, with a no-nonsense demeanor. He had a background in amateur opera, and was classically trained, so he knew what he was doing. And up on the stand he projected authority, with his powerful tenor voice and commanding presence that belied his short stature. He confidently waved a conducting baton, but led with his whole body, and that kind of enthusiasm is infectious. He’s probably long since passed away, but I find myself missing him every Sunday as we slog through another half-hearted rendition of “How Great Thou Art” that started off too slow and gets slower with every verse, with a chorister who doesn’t understand how time signatures work.
I’m not warming up to the new batches of hymns as I thought I would. Like many aspects of the Church, they tend to be getting more shallow and vapid in recent years. I’m a bit surprised at the inclusion of “Amazing Grace”; it’s a lovely song, but due to its subject matter it would have absolutely been considered anathema to the LDS Church I grew up in. I wish they would at least acknowledge this publicly, instead of pretending like we always believed in salvation by grace.
I’m unsure about the inclusion of hymns that are based on traditional Gospel Spirituals (“This Little Light of Mine”, etc.); I like the attempt to broaden cultural representation, and these songs are certainly historically significant, but it still feels a bit like cultural appropriation in my overwhelmingly white suburban ward. Our ward tried singing it with handclaps once, but the congregation couldn’t quite figure out how to clap uniformly on 2 and 4. And no one could fully get past the long-standing taboo of clapping in sacrament meeting, so it was just weird, not joyful or worshipful as it should have been.
Also, I just can’t with that new song “Gethsemane”. The lyrics are trite and platitudinous, and the tune is excrutiating. Perhaps this is by design; having to listen to or sing this song is the musical equivalent of being nailed to a cross.
To echo an earlier comment, I would like to see our church leaning harder into the works of J.S. Bach, Vaughn Williams, and similar ilk.
Unpopular opinion here: I actually like “Praise to the Man”, that is, the music, but not the lyrics. It’s borrowed from Scotland the Brave, and is a rousing and inspirational tune. If someone could set different inspirational lyrics to it to redeem the song, that would make me very happy. I am generally in agreement that many documented aspects of Joseph Smith’s public and private conduct make him unworthy of praise, but I don’t want to throw out the baby with the bathwater, musically speaking.
I would also love to see Church members more fully embrace brass instruments. I absolutely love the sound of brass bands and ensembles. BKP has been dead for some time now, but I still have yet to see a single trumpet or French horn show up in a sacrament meeting thus far.
Jack Hughes: Praise to the Man is a great tune. When I was in college, a group of us would sing it in 4 parts, getting taller and shorter as our parts went up and down. A good leg work out, and a lot of fun. I wouldn’t mind new lyrics at all, though I think it would be hard to get people to ever stop thinking of it as Praise to the Man. If You Could Hie to Kolob is another great tune with strange lyrics.
A couple of weeks ago my primary music leader promised the kids a halloween song. He didn’t really know what that was, but it would probably have been 5 minutes of us singing “5 little pumpkins” or something. But some kid went home and told their parent who then called the primary presidency. Because heaven forbid 6 year olds have any fun at church . . .
Our Utah ward has many fantastic singers, and our stake choir is top notch. And our typical sacrament meeting fills the chapel and most of the cultural hall. Our community choirs at Christmas and Easter are also excellent. So it’s curious why our Sunday worship singing is not very loud or enthusiastic. I’ve not been able to figure it out. It’s roughly the same for the new or old hymns. Seems like most of the time the organ is too loud for the singing, and the few times I’ve filled in for the organist I’ve tried to play softer. We have almost 100 primary children, and the programs are great. I suppose YMMV, but I to disagree with some commenters, I think our primary music is really good—much more fun to play and sing, especially the new modern music. not in the books coming out, ie by Angie Killian, and Shauna Edwards. I think primary music education will continue to keep music alive in the church. And our primary singing is anything but dour and boring. The new children’s music ed we use in primary has the kids up playing rhythm sticks while they sing, singing opera or country style, learning to lead music, acting out the songs, and even dancing. I think it would help to have singing time for adults too, to learn the new hymns. I agree that some of the new hymns are “I” focused. But I think that some are very good and worshipful, ie. most every one that has Jesus in the title, as well as His Voice as the Sound, and This Is the Christ.
Music is life giving to me. I’ve been singing since I was very young and the parents forced piano lessons on me, which I’m grateful for. I sang in all state choirs and the BYU Men’s Chorus. I had a barbershop quartet in high school. Growing up, there was always music playing—mostly classical instrumental and choral. I’ve participated in ward choir, been a primary chorister, and current in my second go-round as the ward choir director. I participate in an auditioned choir based in Utah county. I take singing lessons from an opera singer as well right now. I say all this to illustrate how central music is to my being. I’m so grateful for this other choir I participate in. It is wonderful to be surrounded by other singers who are so good and sing sacred music across traditions and times. If there was ever a place where meaning and cosmic power were both in the room together, I could point you directly to a few choral performances I’ve been.
Music in the church needs to be set free. It is artificially held back by policy. The primary seems to be the only org that can let loose. My ward is prepping for our primary program and the sing through today was great. But, it does seem like all other musical participation in the ward lacks considerably. It is really hard to get people to ward choir and it has been that way for a very long time. Some of the new hymns are great, but I just don’t understand why they added Amazing Grace to This Little Light of Mine—because it is just disgraceful how we sing them. All the life has been sucked out of them to prefer the “quiet dignity” (aka. Christ-like boredom) of sacrament meeting. I just don’t know what we are so afraid of. Do we really think heaven is going to be so drab?
I agree with previous comments that our meetings could use more music, better talks and less of them. General conference would be so much better if they followed the same format they have in the MoTab Christmas concert each year.
I loved the post. There are interesting observations about singing by the masses. It is a tragedy that this “communal singing” is disappearing from our communities. I liken it to athletics. In the not so distant past, every kid was expected to be able to throw and catch a ball. Finding 10 kids to play football/baseball/basketball/street hockey in your neighborhood was easy because all the kids could play. Now, the kids that do play are MUCH better than anything that athletes could do “back in the day”, but the level of proficiency of the median person is much lower. Music is much the same.
When attending the semiannual music performances at the local elementary and middle schools, I am consistently amazed at the inability of these kids to sing a simple Christmas song. Watching the performances, I hear myself thinking “I can tell none of these kids are going to Sunday School”. Then I’ll go to another performance in the same school where certain kids who have specialized in music or acting blow me away with their ability. Same school, but the gap between trained and untrained is huge. Losing communal singing is painfully obvious at that level.
So, I agree. Sing more. Raise a joyful noise.