Trigger warning: This post addresses the death of a child.
If you shook me awake in the middle of the night and asked me what I believed about the Big Questions, I’d tell you I wasn’t certain. Nothing interesting happens after certainty. Not for me, anyway.
Most days, this suits me just fine. I tolerate ambivalence and ambiguity well, by disposition as well as by training.
And, if I’m being honest, when it comes to the terrain between faith and doubt, I don’t live in the place neatly in the middle. My doubts are stronger. That suits me just fine too. I am maybe even a little smug about it, a little self-congratulatory: No cherished delusions here.
It is not generous, in any sense, that way of thinking.
A few days ago, I went to the funeral of a child. He was only twelve. Just a handful of years ago I’d attended the funeral of the boy’s father. This family, they’ve been through a lot.
At the funeral, I hugged the widowed, bereaved mother and tried to stifle my sobs. “I am so sorry. So incredibly sorry,” I told her.
“He died with a smile,” she said. “He’s with his dad now.” She didn’t look happy. But she looked confident.
He had not wanted to die, this boy. He’d begged his mother and his doctors to keep going. “Please. I want to live,” he’d pleaded. But life is horribly, unspeakably cruel.
The family are not, to my knowledge, of any particular faith. But they had faith. Faith that there was purpose in their boy’s life and death, faith in life beyond death in a meaningful if unknowable sense. They have the sort of faith that Alma talks about—the thing that begins as a seed and grows into a tree, a tree so strong that faith isn’t even the right name for it anymore. It’s become something deeper. Surer.
I don’t have anything like that. Oh, I’ve tried. All my Mormon life I have tried. And it hasn’t worked. Maybe my unbelief, dispositional or not, has cast it out. Maybe I haven’t paid the price—and maybe I’m glad I haven’t.
And yet, in my doubting, ambivalent heart, in the rage and despair I feel even now thinking of what that boy and his family have been through, what his mom will go through for the rest of her life, I also think about what she said. Her confidence. And I can’t help but think of Alma’s question.
I still have no answer. But to those who do: thank you.
