Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com

I wanted to acknowledge Good Friday in today’s post, and it turned out very differently than I’d thought. The title and image are a content warning. This post isn’t faith-affirming. If you’re looking for something that will help you honor the Savior today, this post isn’t it. Hit the back button and I hope you have a warm and faithful Easter weekend.

When I was in my mid-twenties, I remember a sacrament meeting talk on Easter Sunday. The speaker was describing Christ’s physical agony in great detail. This was back in the 90s, before we knew words like “triggered.” I was starting to sweat and my head was swimming. Pretending to rub my face, I was actually sticking my fingers in my ears and, when that didn’t work to block out his words, I was bouncing my fingers in my ears to turn the speaker’s words into a meaningless wow-wow-wow. I should have just left. I didn’t.

I’ve always had this problem. I loved my Savior and had many beautiful spiritual experiences with the Atonement. But descriptions of his physical suffering freaked me out and shut me down. As a teenager I picked up a book by Truman J. Madsen about the atonement. Somewhere in that book, Madsen said that whenever he was tempted to sin, he pictured a nail being held against the Savior’s palm and himself being the one to swing the hammer. That’s what sin was to him. After he visualized that, the temptation went away. I was horrified. Every time I sinned, (like daydreaming at Church because I was bored, or yelling at my brother), I was swinging the hammer to drive the nail into Jesus’s hand. I didn’t know the term “intrusive thoughts”. I just couldn’t get that image out of my mind for months. 

I was in my 30s before I got into therapy and started talking out my parents’ relationship. My father had a lot in common with God the Father, in that you could never meet his standards. They changed periodically, he didn’t communicate them very well, and they were always too high for any ordinary human to comply with them. He got really, really angry when we (his kids) failed to live up to his expectations. Sometimes. Other times he was fine. You never knew what was coming. Similar to the way that obedient living sometimes brings blessings from God, but you can’t expect those blessings because that’s the prosperity gospel and that’s false doctrine. Or whatever. You can’t expect punishment for disobedience to be consistent either. The point is, neither God nor my father were super clear on a bunch of things, and you either got punished or you didn’t, but there wasn’t a way to tell ahead of time. Also, I had to believe that God and my father loved me, no matter what.

Fortunately, I had a Savior. Jesus was the Savior who suffered so God the Father wouldn’t send me to hell. My mother was the earthly savior who suffered so my earthly father wouldn’t hit me or hate me for being a failure. She was successful where I was concerned. She couldn’t stop Dad from hitting his sons and being disappointed in his other daughters. I joined my mother in trying to be a savior for our family. If I could just be good enough to atone for my mother’s sins and shortcomings, maybe my father would stop punishing her for everything her children did wrong.

Therapy doesn’t work very fast. It went slow, but when I finally internalized and accepted that my parents’ relationship was horrible and the pressure they put on me was emotional abuse, my testimony of God and Jesus and the Atonement went away. I didn’t intend for that to happen, but I also couldn’t stop it. There were too many similarities between my efforts to please my father because I loved my mother, and my efforts to obey all God’s commandments because I loved Jesus.

I tried thinking harder and talking myself back into having a testimony. Jesus was a God. Jesus did this voluntarily out of love. This was the only way to redeem us. It didn’t work. I can’t handle the emotional patterns underlying the atonement. I can’t have the feelings that underlie a testimony of the atonement without dragging my entire self back into that dysfunctional relationship with my parents. I understand most people don’t have my experiences and don’t feel this way, and that’s fine. I’m not trying to convince anyone; just telling my story.

When I found out that the gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, were actually written decades after Christ died, and mostly written by people who didn’t know Jesus, I was relieved. Maybe all that stuff about him saying he was the Son of God here to atone for the sins of the world was put in later. Fine by me.

The thing is, I love Christ’s teachings. I love his concern for the poor and hungry. I want our entire society to follow his example in offering healing to all the sick. I grit my teeth in anger at religious hypocrisy too. I would have followed him; I love what he taught. I’ve read and studied the New Testament gospels; I’ve taught them in Sunday School. Even though the idea of Christ suffering for my sins horrifies me on a deep and fundamental level, I want to live by his other teachings. How should we treat each other? What do we owe to our fellow humans?

I’ve spent a lot of time pondering Christ’s teachings in light of my loss of testimony. Which principles do I still accept? Would the world be a better place if this particular teaching was universal? In a way, I’ve become more thoughtful about Christ since losing my testimony. I honor him this weekend, just not the way most Christians would want me to.

We have a lot of people here at Wheat and Tares with nuanced testimonies, and a few stalwart faithfuls as well. If you’re comfortable with doing this, please share how your testimony or thoughts about Christ have changed and evolved over your faith journey.

Happy Easter.