It’s traumatizing to have sex you don’t want to have. It’s even more traumatizing when you’re forcing yourself to cooperate with the sex, with a heaping helping of self-hatred and wondering what’s wrong with you.

There. I said it. 

I’ve recently started listening to the Latter Gay Stories podcast, which is excellent and I highly recommend it. So far, the stories from mixed orientation marriages that I’ve listened to involve a gay husband and a straight wife. Usually, the wife knew the husband was gay before they got married. A scenario that I haven’t heard yet is a mixed orientation marriage in which a lesbian wife married a straight husband, and the husband knew she was a lesbian before they got married. (I’ve only listened to a couple dozen stories from the back catalog so maybe I just haven’t run across it yet [fn 1]). 

When someone (a man) comes out of the closet, announces he’s gay, and that he and his wife are getting a divorce, the homophobes holler about selfishness and condemn him for wanting to “live the gay lifestyle.” The underlying idea is that it’s selfish to want to have sex that you enjoy. But what about the corollary? Is it selfish to NOT want to have sex that you DON’T enjoy?

The stories that I haven’t heard told publicly (except for mine because I’m telling it now) involve a wife who was so deeply closeted when she got married that she didn’t even know she was a lesbian or an asexual, and she divorced a straight husband. And friends, those divorces are not about a lesbian wanting to live a wanton and sex-filled life. Those divorces are about trauma. Years of forcing yourself to cooperate with sex you don’t want to have creates so much trauma that it takes years to recover. 

Gay people divorcing straight spouses may include needing space to recover from sexual trauma. I’ve got a lot in common with sexual trauma survivors, even though my sexual trauma was self-inflicted and consensual. I had a conversation with a lesbian about my age (50ish) who had recently divorced a man she’d been married to for more than 20 years and seeing signs of a panic attack that she tried to cover up while we talked through our stories of divorce. I’m not the only one with PTSD from being in a straight marriage. I know I’m not. But we’re all so very quiet. I don’t know if mental health professionals have published anything about the effects of spending years voluntarily having unwanted sex, but if someone knows of a source, please let me know in the comments.

Wikipedia has an entire article about LGBT suicides connected to Mormonism. It’s sobering reading – terrifying, actually. Some of those people who committed suicide were in mixed orientation marriages. I heard about a faithful LDS wife and mother in my stake who, seemingly out of nowhere, tried to die by suicide. I admit my first thought was to wonder if she was a lesbian or asexual, trying to escape her marriage in a way that is more socially acceptable than announcing that she can’t deal with procreative sex and filing for divorce. I don’t know. I don’t know if she was. I just know how I felt, when I was deeply closeted and trying so desperately hard to make a straight marriage work. I remember holding the knife to my wrist and thinking that if I died before my children were old enough to remember me, it wouldn’t cause them as many problems as having an LGBTQ mother. This Church, and homophobic rhetoric, screwed up my thinking that much.

Religious Trauma

I am SO ANGRY at the Church’s teachings that we don’t have bodily autonomy. God created our bodies, teaches the Church, and so God can tell us what to do with our bodies.

What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own?

20 For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God’s. [1 Corinthians 6:19-20]

What this means in practice is that men, who claim to speak for God, make the decisions about women’s bodies. That includes minor decisions like how many ear piercings to have, to major decisions like living the law of chastity – which not only means no sex before marriage, but plenty of procreative sex after marriage to make babies.

My issue with being in a straight marriage was my sexual orientation. But heterosexual women who are pressured to marry men they aren’t attracted to would have a similar issue. If marriage is necessary for social acceptance and economic security, some women will have unwanted sex in exchange for social standing and a place to live. Plenty of heterosexual married women have a good sex life and are very happy – I’m talking about a minority of people, but we matter too.

Women’s rights and gay rights are first and foremost about bodily autonomy – the ability to live a full life without being pressured to be in a straight marriage that presumably includes sex.

Why I Published This

I wasn’t going to publish this essay. The post about being asexual was plenty personal, and this one is even more so. But then I saw the reports in the Salt Lake Tribune about how Utah’s elected representatives are  trying to make the LGBTQ+ community shut up and go away, like we’re somehow icky. “We live in Utah, we shouldn’t have to deal with this stuff.” On the national stage, the Supreme Court is rolling back anti-discrimination laws

The fight for gay rights has rightly focused on the right to marriage equality and equal treatment under the laws. Gays should not face discrimination, ridicule and bullying. Love is love. Marry someone you’re attracted to. Don’t be afraid to love. And so on and so forth. 

My fight for gay rights is the flip side of all that “love is love” rhetoric. Gay rights are also about the right to NOT have sex if you don’t want it. Gay rights mean that society doesn’t pressure women (or men) into straight marriages in search of social standing and economic security. Gay rights and women’s rights mean that a single queer woman can hold the same job a straight married man holds, and make the same salary. Gay rights and women’s rights mean I can qualify for a home mortgage on my own. Gay rights mean that I can marry my queerplatonic best friend so we get all the benefits of marriage, and no one is quizzing us on what our sex life is like. Gay rights mean that a woman or man (or non-binary person) can decide they aren’t interested in having sex at all and it’s no big deal. Gay rights mean that no one tries to pass as straight because they want to avoid the bullying and harm of admitting they’re gay.

Here’s my asexual opinion: Have sex that makes your body feel good. The only thing that really matters is respect for your partner and full and enthusiastic consent. [fn 2]


[fn 1] I listened to the Sunny and Joe Smart episode but neither the husband nor the wife knew the wife was a lesbian before they got married.

[fn 2] I want to yell this at those smug, straight Republican legislators: I HATE YOUR SEX AS MUCH AS YOU HATE QUEER SEX. I also suspect that they are all lousy in bed. Homophobia is based on the idea that no one can have different sexual feelings. Therefore, homophobic men probably don’t know or care if their wives enjoy sex. I am petty enough that when someone says gay sex is unnatural and icky, I automatically assume that he’s so selfish in bed that his wife is secretly hoping that he will come down with an untreatable case of erectile dysfunction.  


Questions for discussion

  1. How about we allow bodily autonomy for everyone on every issue?
  2. Why don’t homophobes understand that sex is a matter of personal preference and their orgasms aren’t inherently superior to gay orgasms?
  3. Why are homophobes so insecure that they feel their entire way of life is threatened if someone doesn’t have the same feelings about sex that they do?